Tom Gabel of Against Me recently came out as transgender, prompting a media frenzy around this declaration of personal independence. It was, I gotta say, a very punk rock move coming from a band I always thought of as Not Very Punk. It earned my respect.
I should confess that I can be a punk purist. I wanna know what kind of cred someone is bringing to an album. I look down my nose on Green Day. I don’t like “sell-outs.” I learned about punk from a homeless guy on Westheimer named Justin who was so dedicated to his punk beliefs that he wouldn’t work for The Man, wouldn’t do anything against his credo, and he was willing to sleep by a dumpster for that belief. He had homemade tattoos and piercings, had done a lot of drugs, and was–at the time–attending a street mission targeted at teaching God’s word to street people. When we met, I thought Justin was terrifying–I was 15, he was…God knows how old, beneath all the dirt, but maybe 30–and possibly the only genuine person I’d ever known in my life. He treated me with a brand of gruff kindness that blew my mind, called me Rapunzel for my knack of climbing onto roofs and up trees, and would talk philosophy with me like I was an adult. I loved him fiercely, but I don’t think he ever knew it. He’s been my standard of what a punk should be ever since.
So Against Me… Eh. They were all right. I didn’t feel like there was any of the “fuck the man” mentality to their music that I crave from punk. I didn’t feel the outsider vibe, the world-shaking rage or deep philosophical frustration. But now…well, now I think that Laura Jane Grace, formerly known as Tom Gabel, is one badass babe. I want to know what songs are in her soul now she’s living an authentic life free of societal constructs, free to express a real pain, a real anger with the world. I didn’t believe Tom Gabel could rock, but I sure as hell think Laura Jane Grace will.
I could stop here, but I don’t think it would be honest. I don’t think I’d be expressing my own authentic self. I can’t laud Laura for speaking out when I don’t do the same.
If I’m gonna have a true, “fuck the man” punk moment here… I should out myself as transgender too. I should confess that I have mental problems associated with being female-bodied when everything inside me protests it. I tried, like Tom Gabel, to make do with half-measures and fake-it-til-you-make-it attitudes my entire life. I don’t believe at all that Tom Gabel just wanted publicity. She could have achieved it any number of less extreme ways.
Tell me honestly… Do you think a rock star would cut off his penis to be more famous? I don’t think even Spencer Pratt wanted to be famous that badly.
It’s not about publicity. It’s not even about sex. Sure, sex can be…awkward and feel wrong when you’re working with the wrong kind of plumbing, but the real reason anyone is transgender is that something is horribly wrong with their meatsuit. Something is so wrong with their body that they can never shake the feeling. Something like a gross tumor is there that should not be or, for me, missing.
For me, my absent cock is like a phantom limb. I can feel where it should be, feel sensations there with my mind in a place that can’t be touched. When I sleep, it’s there in my dreams, if they’re good ones. My brain believes it’s there, but my flesh lacks that particular part. Nothing will ever feel right without it. Fuck masculinity, fuck gender roles, fuck whether or not I ever have another sexual partner. None of it matters.
It isn’t about sex. It isn’t even about gender. It’s about feeling a pervasive, unshakable, unremitting wrongness that makes caring for my own body a loathsome chore. I hate this body. I hate it with such a passion that it defies description. It’s hard to inhabit this shell, hard to bathe it and dress it and care if it’s sick. It feels foreign, repulsive, hateful. I struggle to take the medicine that I need to be well. I struggle to joke and shrug off things like menstruation, which feel like a nightmare from Hell. I struggle to lose weight, to exercise, to do anything which acknowledges this flesh is real, because all I want is to be free of it, to be a disembodied soul who no longer feels suffocated by that misshapen cage.
There are several self-identified FTM transgender people in the writing community, but I’ve shied away from them. I’ve avoided ever coming out like this. I don’t want to be painted with that brush or branded with their label. I do not reveal this to titillate. I do not want to discuss my sexual escapades.
There is an air of…fetishism, almost, that surrounds some self-identified FTMs. If that is the life they want to lead, more power to them, but it is not the life I want. It is not who I am. I’m not going to be the bottom unless I know a man well enough to feel respected, and I’m not going to let him use my “bonus hole” because it should not exist. If you’re FTM and you don’t mind letting guys plow your pussy, if you can do that and still feel like a man, good for you. I can’t. I sure as hell wouldn’t talk about it like I was some prize uke from a genderfuck yaoi, and I see a hell of a lot of that around the internet.
I talk to people who think FTMs are fangirls who let the slash fiction go to their heads. I talk to people who think FTMs are girls who feel repressed by femininity and want to “play at” being a man so they can be dirty and promiscuous. I talk to people who think that FTMs hate women, are anti-feminist, are brainwashed by the male-establishment, and need to just embrace their lesbianism. So yeah, it comes from both sides. It comes from all sides. It makes me hesitate to publish this blog post.
I love women. I love men. I love humanity, for all its faults. Life is beautiful, indescribably so, and precious. Love is infinite and more powerful than most people comprehend. There’s such a heartbreaking wonderfulness just to surviving day to day that despite all the wrong in my everyday life, I cannot help feeling the most profound gratitude and joy that this is my life, that I am alive. I do not hate myself, not at all. I hate this fleshy cage in which I’m trapped, but I love who I am underneath. I love the man beneath all this meaty ruin that hides from a world that misunderstands him and fights it without ceasing, waiting for a way to be integrated into a world with no room for him.